How to Determine Your Weight Gain Pattern to Pick a Weight Loss Medication or Lifestyle Plan
Almost everything in life follows a certain rhythm, from setting goals to practicing gratitude, building relationships to enjoying hobbies. Even bad habits have their own cycles. Recognizing these patterns is crucial when you're trying to add a new habit to your life. By understanding how your body works, you can fit new habits in more easily and catch bad habits before they become routines.
Did you know weight gain has a pattern too?
In this episode, we'll explore the different factors that drive eating and overeating. These reasons can vary greatly, making it tough to stick to our nutrition plans. We'll talk about the weight gain pattern, how to recognize it, and how to choose the right plan for you. Whether it's weight loss meds, changing your diet, or trying new exercises, we'll help you find what works best for you.
I also want to discuss the four eating patterns identified by Dr. Andres Acosta: The Hungry Brain, Emotional Hunger, Hungry Gut, and Slow Burners. He used some fascinating scientific methods to uncover these different eating habits. I’ll also share my own thoughts and approach that can help you improve your health plan.
Slow Burner: Why Your Metabolism Might Be Slower and How to Fix It
Let's start with the "Slow Burner" pattern because it’s one of the most straightforward to explain. This group is unique and also the smallest. Slow Burners are people with a low metabolic rate, meaning they burn fewer calories than expected. This typically happens because smaller or older individuals naturally burn fewer calories.
To identify a Slow Burner, tests are usually done while the person is fasting and at rest, measuring how many calories they burn just lying there. Some people naturally burn fewer calories, and this can be especially evident when their activity level and diet don’t seem to match up with their weight struggles.
If you've tried various diets and exercise plans without success, you might be a Slow Burner. Metabolic testing available at some clinics can help confirm this. Additionally, low muscle mass can contribute to a slower metabolism. This is often seen in postmenopausal women who have lost muscle mass, resulting in a lower metabolic rate.
For slow burners, one effective solution is to increase muscle mass through resistance training. If you’re looking for a simple, home-based program, check out GLP Strong. It’s designed to be easy and effective, with just twice-a-week, 20-minute sessions to give you the strength training you need.
So, if you think you might be a Slow Burner, boosting your muscle mass with resistance training could be a game-changer.
Hungry Gut: How to Handle Frequent Hunger and Stay Satisfied
The "Hungry Gut" pattern describes people whose stomachs empty quickly, making them feel hungry sooner. If you find you can’t go as long between meals because your stomach constantly signals hunger, you might be dealing with this pattern.
A Hungry Gut means your digestive system prompts you to eat more frequently, which can make sticking to a meal plan challenging. Here are a few strategies to manage it:
1. Choose High-Fiber Foods: Foods rich in fiber, like vegetables, fruits, and whole grains, help you feel fuller longer by slowing digestion.
2. Incorporate Protein: Adding protein to your meals can improve satiety. Lean meats, beans, nuts, and dairy are great options.
3. Eat Smaller, More Frequent Meals: Instead of three large meals, try eating smaller meals more frequently throughout the day to manage hunger better.
4. Stay Hydrated: Drinking enough water can help you feel fuller and reduce the urge to snack unnecessarily.
By adjusting your diet and eating habits, you can better manage a Hungry Gut and maintain a more balanced eating routine.
Hungry Brain: How to Overcome Persistent Cravings and Feel Satisfied
The "Hungry Brain" pattern refers to people who don’t feel fully satisfied after eating. They might finish a meal and still crave a snack or find themselves eating more than necessary because their brain doesn’t signal fullness effectively.
For those dealing with a Hungry Brain, here are some strategies to manage it:
1. Mindful Eating: Pay attention to your hunger and fullness cues while eating. Eat slowly and savor your food to help your brain recognize when you’re satisfied.
2. Balanced Meals: Ensure your meals include a mix of protein, fiber, and healthy fats. These nutrients help increase satiety and can keep you feeling fuller for longer.
3. Healthy Snacks: Keep nutritious snacks on hand, such as fruits, nuts, or yogurt, to manage cravings without overindulging.
4. Stay Hydrated: Drink water throughout the day. Sometimes, dehydration can be mistaken for hunger.
By focusing on mindful eating and making balanced food choices, you can help manage a Hungry Brain and reduce the urge to snack unnecessarily.
Emotional Hunger: How to Address Eating for Pleasure and Emotional Relief
The "Emotional Hunger" pattern involves eating for emotional reasons rather than physical hunger. This often includes eating for pleasure, seeking a dopamine rush, or using food as a way to cope with stress or emotions.
People with Emotional Hunger might find themselves eating when they get home from work to unwind, snacking during stressful workdays, or eating more when they feel sad, lonely, or even happy and celebratory. They might be the ones who seek comfort in food or indulge when celebrating with friends.
To manage Emotional Hunger, consider these strategies:
1. Identify Triggers: Recognize the emotional situations that lead you to eat. Keeping a journal can help you spot patterns and triggers.
2. Find Alternatives: Look for non-food ways to address your emotions, such as exercise, hobbies, or talking with friends.
3. Practice Mindfulness: Pay attention to your eating habits and emotions. Mindful eating can help you understand whether you're eating out of true hunger or for emotional reasons.
4. Build Healthy Routines: Create new routines that don’t revolve around food, like taking a walk after work or engaging in a relaxing activity to help manage stress.
By addressing emotional triggers and finding healthier coping mechanisms, you can better manage Emotional Hunger and maintain a more balanced approach to eating.
Beyond the Patterns
While 85% of people fit into one of the eating patterns discussed, about 15% don’t fall neatly into these categories. So, who are these 15%?
They often face unique challenges such as gaps in knowledge or resources related to healthy eating. Some may not know what they should be eating, lack skills in calorie counting, or struggle with access to nutritious foods due to financial or geographic limitations.
Other barriers include having very restricted diets due to sensory issues or disordered eating patterns, which might have developed over many years and make it hard to include a variety of foods.
Additionally, eating disorders like binge eating disorder can overlap with patterns such as Hungry Gut or Hungry Brain, and these disorders often have separate biological drivers. Not everyone with an eating disorder struggles with obesity, and some individuals with the disease obesity might not have an eating disorder.
Finally, emerging areas like the gut microbiome might also play a role, and there may be other factors yet to be understood. Addressing these challenges involves improving nutrition knowledge, finding ways to access healthier food options, and tackling underlying issues related to eating behaviors and health.
Key Questions to Understand Your Eating Patterns
To figure out your relationship with food, start by reflecting on a few key areas. Here are some questions and explanations to guide you:
1. What Has Worked for You in the Past?
- Understanding what has been effective for you before can provide valuable insights. If certain diets, like keto or Weight Watchers, worked well for you in the past but didn't stick, or if intense exercise was once part of your routine, this information is crucial. It helps identify what might have changed and why certain strategies may no longer be effective.
2. What Does a Typical Day of Eating Look Like?
- Write down what you typically eat for each meal. For example, note your usual breakfast, and how you feel afterward. Are you satisfied or still hungry? Does what you eat affect how long you feel full? This can help you understand if certain foods keep you fuller longer or if you're eating less nutritious options that don’t sustain you.
3. How Do You Feel Before Your Next Meal?
- Assess your hunger levels as mealtime approaches. Are you hungry, or do you eat based on the clock or social cues? Understanding whether you eat because you’re genuinely hungry or simply because it’s mealtime can shed light on your eating patterns.
4. What Happens Between Meals?
- Reflect on your hunger between lunch and dinner. Are you frequently hungry due to long gaps between meals? This can help identify if you need more frequent meals or snacks to manage your hunger better.
5. How Do You Feel After Dinner?
- Note how you feel after dinner. Do you feel satisfied, or do you find yourself grazing or snacking excessively? This can indicate whether you’re truly full, or if emotional or habitual eating is influencing your behavior.
6. Are You a Foodie?
- Consider if you’re particularly focused on food, planning meals, and finding pleasure in eating. If you’re constantly thinking about food, trying new recipes, or watching cooking shows, it might impact how you approach eating and managing cravings.
7. Do You Experience Binge Eating?
- Reflect on whether you sometimes eat out of control, consuming more than typical in one sitting. Binge eating often involves eating large amounts of food quickly and feeling physically or emotionally distressed afterward. Identifying these patterns can help determine if you need a specialized approach to manage binge eating.
These questions can help clarify your eating behaviors and identify areas that might require changes or more in-depth exploration.
Addressing Various Eating Patterns: Strategies and Solutions
Achieving successful weight management often requires a personalized approach, as individual eating patterns can significantly influence weight gain and loss. Recognizing and addressing these patterns is key to finding effective solutions.
Hungry Brain: This term, as identified by Dr. Acosta, refers to those who always crave more, even after eating a full meal. While his research initially focused on older GLP-1 medications like Liraglutide, we now have more effective options available.
Solutions for Hungry Brain:
Medications: GLP-1 injectables (like Wegovy or Zepbound) and Phentermine-Topiramate (brand name Qsymia) can be effective. These medications help manage persistent hunger and cravings.
Diet Adjustments: Incorporate protein-rich foods into your meals to enhance feelings of satiety. Foods high in fiber, like fruits, vegetables, and whole grains, can also help. Avoid ultra-processed snacks that trigger excessive eating.
Emotional Hunger: Emotional hunger, or eating driven by feelings rather than physical need, is often related to seeking pleasure or comfort from food. This can include eating when stressed, sad, or seeking a dopamine boost.
Solutions for Emotional Hunger:
Medications: Contrave, which combines bupropion and naltrexone, is effective for managing cravings and emotional eating.
Non-Medication Strategies: Address stress through methods such as meditation, therapy, or cognitive-behavioral techniques. Practice mindful eating and find alternative ways to manage emotions, such as journaling or taking a walk.
Hungry Gut: Some people experience rapid stomach emptying, which leads to frequent feelings of hunger shortly after eating.
Solutions for Hungry Gut:
Diet Adjustments: Opt for small, frequent meals with high protein and fiber content. This helps maintain satiety longer. If eating less frequently leads to overeating or grazing, adjust to five smaller, planned meals each day.
Medications: Some people do find medications like GLP-1 injectables (like Wegovy or Zepbound) can offer benefits in slowing down transit time during and after meals.
Meal Timing: Eating more frequently can prevent extreme hunger and help manage overeating.
Slow Burners: Individuals with a slow metabolic rate burn fewer calories and may struggle to lose weight despite their efforts.
Solutions for Slow Burners:
Medications: Phentermine can slightly boost metabolic rate.
Exercise: Incorporate resistance or strength training to increase muscle mass and boost metabolism.
Considerations for Complex Cases:
Combination Patterns: You may identify with multiple eating patterns, such as emotional eating and a slow metabolic rate. If this is the case, a combination of solutions may be needed. For example, you might need both medication and dietary adjustments to manage your weight effectively.
Understanding these patterns and implementing the right strategies can provide clarity and support for achieving your health goals.
Sensory Specific Satiety
One concept that wasn’t included in Dr. Acosta's research but is worth mentioning is sensory specific satiety. This refers to the idea that specific sensory inputs from food—like taste, texture, and the act of chewing—play a crucial role in feeling full and satisfied.
For instance, if you find that you don’t feel satiated after consuming liquids, like protein shakes, and need something to chew, you might be experiencing sensory specific satiety. This was particularly evident to me after some dental work this year, where I had to rely on protein shakes. Despite being full, I didn't feel satisfied because I missed the act of chewing. In contrast, a protein bar would be more satisfying because it provides that necessary sensory input.
Understanding Sensory Specific Satiety:
- Chewing Requirement: Some people need to chew their food to feel full. If you’re one of those individuals, consider incorporating more solid foods or snacks that require chewing into your diet.
- Personal Preferences: What works for others, like feeling full from salads, might not work for you. If salads don’t provide the satisfaction you need, try exploring other foods or textures that meet your satiety needs.
Recognizing and accommodating your unique sensory preferences can help you find more effective ways to manage your hunger and satisfaction.
Knowing your eating patterns can make all the difference in managing your weight. To learn more about these patterns and how to address them, listen to the full episode.
More from The Dr. Francavilla Show:
Subscribe to The Dr. Francavilla Show on
Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, iHeartRadio, Stitcher